
17 Oct Real Estate Commission Changes: What Buyers & Sellers Must Know
I
In recent months, the real estate world has seen a significant shift in how commissions are handled, which has stirred confusion among homebuyers, sellers, and even some industry professionals. These changes, largely driven by a legal settlement with the National Association of Realtors (NAR), have introduced new rules regarding how commissions are disclosed and negotiated during the sale of a home.
The impact of these changes could be far-reaching, potentially altering how buyers and sellers approach the homebuying process. In this post, we’ll explore these changes, explain why they matter, and offer insights on how both buyers and sellers can navigate the evolving real estate landscape.
Understanding Real Estate Commissions: How They Used to Work
Before diving into what’s new, let’s first understand how real estate commissions have traditionally worked. In the past, when a homeowner decided to sell their property, they would typically hire a real estate agent to list the property. This agent, known as the listing agent, would agree on a commission rate with the seller, usually a percentage of the home’s sale price. This rate would then be split between the listing agent and the buyer’s agent.
The Multiple Listing Service (MLS), a database where real estate agents list properties for sale, played a significant role in this process. Agents would list not only the property details but also the commission being offered to the buyer’s agent, which was visible to other agents but not necessarily to the public. Buyers typically didn’t concern themselves with these commissions, as they were almost always paid by the seller as part of the transaction.
Here’s a simplified example: a seller agrees to pay a 5% commission. Half of that commission would go to the listing agent, and the other half would go to the buyer’s agent. This split was standard practice, and buyers were not expected to pay their agents directly.
What Has Changed with Real Estate Commissions?
As a result of a recent lawsuit against the NAR, several significant changes have been introduced to the real estate commission process. The most notable changes include:
- Buyers Must Now Sign a Buyer’s Agreement: One of the new rules requires that buyers sign an agreement with their real estate agent before they can view properties. This agreement outlines the terms under which the agent will represent the buyer and how the agent will be compensated. Essentially, buyers must now acknowledge their agent’s commission and how it will be paid.
- Commissions Are No Longer Visible on the MLS: Under the old system, the commission offered to the buyer’s agent was typically listed in the MLS, where other agents could see it. Now, commissions are not displayed on the MLS, which has made it more challenging for agents to know upfront how much they’ll be compensated when working with a buyer.
- Buyers May Have to Pay Their Agent’s Commission: Perhaps the biggest change is that, in some cases, buyers may now have to pay their agent’s commission directly. This is a departure from the traditional model, where the seller covered both the listing agent’s and the buyer’s agent’s commissions. While this won’t happen in every transaction, it is a possibility that buyers need to be aware of and plan for.
Why These Changes Matter to Buyers and Sellers
These changes have raised a lot of questions, especially among homebuyers who are not accustomed to thinking about paying their agent’s commission out of pocket. Historically, buyers have been more focused on the down payment, closing costs, and securing financing, with the assumption that the seller would cover the commission. Now, buyers might find themselves needing to negotiate who pays the commission or even covering it themselves.
For sellers, the changes also introduce new considerations. Sellers now have to decide whether they will offer to cover the buyer’s agent’s commission as part of the transaction. If they choose not to, they might reduce the number of potential buyers, as some buyers might not be able to afford both the purchase price of the home and their agent’s commission. This dynamic could impact how competitive a property is in the marketplace.
Negotiating Real Estate Commissions: Still an Option
One point that remains unchanged is that real estate commissions are still negotiable. As noted in the transcript, “commissions have always been negotiable” and “they always will be.” Whether you’re a buyer or a seller, it’s important to remember that you have the option to negotiate commission rates with your agent.
For sellers, this might mean negotiating a lower overall commission or deciding how much of the commission will be offered to the buyer’s agent. Some sellers may choose to offer a lower commission to the buyer’s agent in order to save money. However, it’s important to understand that this could make the property less attractive to agents representing buyers, potentially leading to fewer showings and a longer time on the market.
For buyers, the new rules might mean negotiating directly with their agent about who will cover their commission. In some cases, buyers may ask the seller to cover the commission as part of the purchase price or may try to negotiate a lower commission with their agent. It’s worth noting that many agents may be willing to negotiate their fees, especially in competitive markets.
The Benefits of Increased Transparency
While these changes may seem daunting at first, one of the clear benefits is increased transparency. Buyers now have more insight into how their agent is compensated and can make more informed decisions about their real estate transactions. This transparency can help prevent confusion down the road, particularly when it comes to understanding the costs associated with buying a home.
The new rules also help to clarify the roles of real estate agents and the value they bring to the table. In the past, many buyers may not have fully understood the work their agent was doing on their behalf, especially if they were unaware of how commissions worked. Now, with commissions being a more open topic of discussion, agents have the opportunity to clearly explain the services they provide and why they are worth the commission.
This increased transparency is beneficial for both buyers and sellers, as it allows for more open conversations about costs and ensures that everyone involved in the transaction is on the same page.
Challenges Buyers and Sellers Might Face
As with any significant change, there are bound to be challenges. One of the main challenges for buyers is the potential for increased costs. If a buyer is required to pay their agent’s commission, they may need to come up with additional funds on top of their down payment and closing costs. For some buyers, especially first-time buyers, this could be a significant financial burden.
However, as noted in the transcript, many sellers will likely still be open to covering the buyer’s agent’s commission, especially with the right offer. This means that while buyers should be aware of the potential for additional costs, they should also remember that commissions are negotiable and can often be factored into the overall purchase price.
For sellers, the challenge lies in making their property attractive to buyers. If a seller chooses not to offer a commission to the buyer’s agent, they risk reducing the pool of potential buyers, as some buyers may not be able to afford the extra expense. Sellers need to carefully consider how their commission decisions will impact the marketability of their home.
The Role of a Realtor: Why Commissions Are Worth It
One of the key takeaways from the recent changes is the renewed focus on the value of real estate agents. As commissions become a more visible part of the transaction, agents have the opportunity to demonstrate the full scope of their services and why they are worth the commission.
Real estate agents do far more than simply show homes. They are skilled negotiators, market experts, and advisors who guide their clients through one of the most significant financial decisions of their lives. From marketing the property and negotiating offers to navigating inspections and closing, real estate agents handle a wide range of tasks that are crucial to the success of a transaction.
As the transcript points out, buyers and sellers often don’t realize just how much work goes into a real estate transaction until they’re in the middle of it. Agents are there to protect their clients’ interests, ensure that contracts are properly executed, and help their clients make informed decisions every step of the way.
Conclusion: Navigating the New Landscape
The changes to real estate commissions have introduced new complexities into the homebuying and selling process, but they also offer an opportunity for greater transparency and fairness. Buyers and sellers alike need to be aware of the new rules and how they may impact their transactions. By working closely with a knowledgeable real estate agent, both buyers and sellers can navigate these changes and ensure that their interests are protected.
Ultimately, while the way commissions are handled may have changed, the core of real estate transactions remains the same: it’s about finding the right home, negotiating a fair deal, and working with a trusted professional to make the process as smooth as possible. Whether you’re buying or selling a home, understanding the new rules and being prepared to negotiate will help you succeed in today’s evolving real estate market.